By Tracie Sullivan, For Iron County Today
Southern Utah University was the first to forfeit a volleyball match against San José State last week, followed by several other schools, amid speculation there was a transgender player on the Spartans’ team.
Following SUU’s decision, Boise State University canceled its Sept. 28 match against San José State, along with Utah State University, which opted out of its Oct. 23 match.
The University of Wyoming, who initially planned to proceed with its scheduled game, later reversed course after what the athletic department described as a “lengthy discussion.” No specific reason was given for the change.
While national media reports have suggested that these forfeitures are related to the presence of transgender player Blaire Fleming on San José State’s roster, none of the universities involved have confirmed whether this was the deciding factor.
In a media statement to Iron County Today, the school simply said, “The Southern Utah University volleyball team opted to compete in just two non-conference games at the Santa Clara Tournament. Southern Utah informed the tournament directors and opposing teams of the decision, and we wish them well with the remainder of their respective seasons.”
The university declined to provide further comment or answer questions regarding the forfeiture, despite Iron County Today’s request for more information.
The controversy surrounding the inclusion of transgender athletes in women’s sports stems from broader national debates.
Critics argue that transgender women, who were assigned male at birth, may have physical advantages in strength and speed that could make competitions unfair.
Supporters, however, argue that transgender athletes should be allowed to compete in alignment with their “identity,” pointing out that the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) has specific guidelines, including requirements for maintaining certain testosterone levels before competing.